Review and comparison skill for your AI agent
Find the improvements that matter. Check the revision.
Review and comparison skill for your AI agent
Find the improvements that matter. Check the revision.
Review how useful, clear, credible, and well-presented a tool, site, skill, or portfolio is. CraftAssay gives your agent a method for prioritizing improvements with evidence, then comparing a later revision to see what was resolved and what remains.
Four review files, seven dimensions. An assessment, not a certification. The source stays unchanged.
HarborNote is a fictional notes app. These excerpts connect its sample review, the author’s revised page, and the later comparison.
1 · Original page Can my notes leave this device?
“Nothing leaves your machine. Ever.”
“Syncs to every laptop you own.”
The page offers both claims without explaining how they fit together.
2 · CraftAssay finding Fix the claim before polishing the pitch
harbornote-F001 · P1 · claim-risk
Surface: the page’s privacy and sync claims.
A privacy-seeking reader cannot tell what stays local. Name which data stays on the machine when sync is off.
P1 is the highest priority. The finding gives the author a specific correction to make.
3 · Author edit + later review The choice is now explicit
Notes stay on this device unless you turn on sync.
Later comparison: harbornote-F001 → resolved
Readers can distinguish local notes from optional sync. The review checks that the contradiction is gone.
This is a review of fictional copy, not a privacy audit. The author makes the edit. Scores support the finding: Accuracy moves from 3 to 6; Utility stays 6.
What it reads, writes, and changes
| Reads | A tool, site, skill, spec, portfolio, URL, or paste |
| Writes | A dated run folder: report.md, a scorecard, findings, and coverage |
| Changes | Nothing. Read the findings, then make the smallest useful correction yourself or ask the agent for that named edit |
| Label | Means |
|---|---|
| Review | Inspect, assess, score, and recommend |
| Findings | Specific issues with evidence and the smallest useful correction |
| Scores | Seven dimensions from 1 to 10, or NR (not rated) when evidence is missing |
| Evidence | What was inspected, and what was not |
| Compare versions | Finding status and explained score changes |
Accuracy is freedom from misleading claims in the inspected presentation. It is not a measured bug rate.
CraftAssay and Cold-eye
Cold-eye asks whether a newcomer can use what is presented as ready. CraftAssay asks how useful, clear, credible, and well-presented the work is. First-use friction still belongs in a CraftAssay finding when it affects those scores. CraftAssay does not issue a release-readiness verdict. A clean Cold-eye review does not mean CraftAssay will score the work highly.
Smell Check reviews unearned language. Detangler reviews what editing tangled.
Built by Catalyst Forge LLC. MIT. About